September 24, 2024 | Jesse Singer

One-Hit Wonders You Forgot Had A Second Hit


One Time, Two Times

The one-hit wonder is a staple of pop music history. But not all one-hit wonders are created equal. Some of them didn't disappear into musical obscurity as fast as you may think, and there are a number of so-called one-hit wonders who actually had a second hit song.

Vanilla Ice

While everyone remembers "Ice Ice Baby" was a hit song, you might not remember how big it really was. "Ice Ice Baby" was the first hip-hop track to ever top the Billboard Hot 100 and his album, To the Extreme, was certified seven times platinum and held the top spot on the Billboard 200 for 16 consecutive weeks—although none of it might've happened had it not been for David Morales.

Recording Artist Vanilla Ice in dark outfitStreamy Awards, Flickr

Advertisement

Vanilla Ice

You see, "Ice Ice Baby" was originally released as the B-side for Ice's song, "Play That Funky Music". However, David Morales was a radio DJ who played "Ice Ice Baby" instead of the A-side track and it was at that point that the song blew up. But what happened to "Play That Funky Music"? Well, we've all forgotten about it because of how huge and one-hit wonderish" Ice Ice Baby" was—but when "Play That Funky Music" was rereleased after the success of the aforementioned "Ice Ice Baby", it became a legit hit in its own right. The song reached platinum status and reached number four on the Hot 100.

Recording artist Rob Van Winkle aka Vanilla Ice at Times SquareDebby Wong, Shutterstock

The Rembrandts

What's the first thing that comes to mind when you hear The Rembrandts? Well, unless you were an art history major, we assume it's the hit television show, Friends. Because, as we all know, the Rembrandts song, "I'll Be There for You" was the show's ubiquitous theme song (insert hand claps here).

The Rembrandts performs the official music video for the Friends theme songKevin Mazur, Getty Images

The Rembrandts

Friends premiered in 1994 and put all six stars, as well as the Rembrandts, on the map. But what gets forgotten is that the band had already had a legit hit four years prior with the song "Just the Way It Is, Baby". In fact, While "I'll Be There for You" reached number 17 on the charts, "Just the Way It Is, Baby" actually topped out even higher at 14 in 1990.

Musicians from The Rembrandts, Phil Solem and ‎Danny WildeAstrid Stawiarz, Getty Images

Advertisement

Marky Mark And The Funky Bunch

While Mark Wahlberg is one of the biggest stars in Hollywood today, back in the '80s, the Wahlberg taking the world by storm was his older brother, Donnie—as a member of The New Kids on the Block. But come 1991, the younger sibling had his moment in the pop music spotlight with his own number one hit, "Good Vibrations"—the first track off his debut album.

American hip hop group Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch, circa 1990Tim Roney, Getty Images

Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch

"Good Vibrations" was such a big hit many of us have forgotten the second single he released that same year—"Wild Side". But while many of us don't remember it today, back in 1991, the Lou Reed-sampled song rose up to number 10 on the Billboard Hot 100.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of American singer and actor Marky Mark Mark WahlbergMichel Linssen, Getty Images

Dream

The girl group Dream lived the pop music dream for a couple years at the turn of the century. After signing with Bad Boy Records, they put out their first album in 2001 and it rose all the way up to number six on the charts—mostly on the back of their catchy debut single, "He Loves U Not". The song was all over the radio and hit number two on the Hot 100. But they weren't done quite yet.

The Girl Group Dream performs in Broomfield, Coloradojenniferlinneaphotography, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Dream

The second single off of the album was called "This Is Me"—and while audiences didn't love it as much as the previous single, it did get up to 39 on the Hot 100 and rose all the way up to 13 on the pop charts.

The Girl Group Dream performs in Broomfield, Coloradojenniferlinneaphotography, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Ugly Kid Joe

California band Ugly Kid Joe had a hit in 1992 with "Everything About You"listing off everything they hated. But we're pretty sure they didn't hate having a number nine hit on the charts. You know what else they didn't hate?

American rock band Ugly Kid Joe performing at Sofia RocksMrPanyGoff, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Ugly Kid Joe

Having a number six hit on the charts the following year with their take on the Harry Chapin classic, "Cat's in the Cradle".

Ugly Kid Joe playing in Viersen, Germany, 2013Heiner Bach, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons 

Advertisement

Young M.C.

From Raj and Leonard at karaoke night to pretty much every wedding you ever go to, "Bust a Move" is still an ever-present part of all our lives. Just as it was back in 1989, when Young M.C. became a crossover success and rode the track up to number seven on the charts. But, to paraphrase Young M.C., what came next...

Young Mc At The 1990 GrammysAlan Light, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Young M.C.

Well, it wasn't another top 10 hit that would engrain itself into our music subconscious. But it was "Principal's Office," which peaked at 33 on the Hot 100 and earned a Best Rap Video nomination at the 1990 MTV Video Music Awards.

Young Mc Photo Op Galaxycon Raleigh 2021Super Festivals, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Cutting Crew

If you were around in the '80s, or if you've ever streamed any number of '80s-themed Spotify stations, you will be familiar with Cutting Crew's debut single, "(I Just) Died In Your Arms"It's one of many classics of the power-ballad era and was a number one hit for the British band. It wasn't their only hit though.

Grayscale Portrait Photo of Cutting Crew BandMattlegg42, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Cutting Crew

The second single off of the same album did quite well also. "I've Been In Love Before" didn't reach number one, but it did get into the top 10 at number nine. Also, on the Adult Contemporary charts, it went as high as number two—whereas the previous track had only hit 24 there.

Portrait Photo of Nick Van Eede, smiling, facing the cameraMattlegg42, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

A-ha

Not only did A-ha score a number one song with "Take on Me" in 1985, they also created one of the most memorable music videos of all time with their live-action and animated creation.

A-ha in concert at Palacio Vistalegre, Madrid, Spain, in 2010Jamesbond raul, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

A-ha

For most of us, that song and its accompanying video was the complete A-ha experience. But their follow up single, "Take on Me" was a pretty legitimate hit as well. Not on par with Take on Me of course—but "The Sun Always Shines on TV" hit number one on the UK Singles charts and number 20 on the Hot 100. They never entered the Hot 100 again.

A-ha live at Cologne, 29 October 2005User, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Jesus Jones

With their second album, Doubt, Jesus Jones saw themselves breakthrough in North America—helped by the hit single "Right Here, Right Now". American listeners latched on to the track and the band saw it hit number two on the Hot 100. So, were they a one-hit wonder or the real, real, real deal?

English rock band Jesus Jones perform in Melbourne, AustraliaCanley, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Jesus Jones

Did you get the joke? Probably not. Which kind of proves the point, really. Because while "Right Here, Right Now" is the song we all remember, their next single "Real, Real, Real" isn't. Although, it did impressively rock its way up to number four on the charts (their only other song to ever even enter the Hot 100).

Mike Edwards of Jesus Jones performs in Asbury Park, NJConstantino14, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Quiet Riot

In 1983, Quiet Riot remade the Slade hit, "Cum on Feel the Noize"—and found even more success with it. Riot's version was the first single off of their album Metal Health and quickly rose up the charts to sit at number five. But while the girls were rocking their boys, Quiet Riot had another hit song that you may have forgotten about.

The Metal Health-era lineup of the band Quiet RiotThe Howlin' Wolf, CC BY-SA 2.5, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Quiet Riot

The title track off of the Metal Health album was the next single and with plenty of MTV love, the song got as high as 31 on the Billboard Hot 100 (the last time the band would see the top 40).

Sean Manning & Kevin Dubrow from the band Quiet RiotFish123321, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Men Without Hats

Who needs hats when you have "The Safety Dance"? Men Without Hats danced if they wanted to and so did lots of people around the world, making this 1983 song an international hit and landing it at number three on the Billboard Hot 100. "The Safety Dance" was the second single off of the band's first album, Rhythm of Youth, and propelled said album to number eight on the Billboard 200. However, after their second album didn't get any higher than 127, it looked like their one-hit wonder status was pretty much set...

Men Without Hats performing at the Burlington Music FestivalTabercil, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Men Without Hats

But then came album number three, Pop Goes the World, and the title track which landed at 20 on the US Hot 100—as well as number one in Australia and number two in Canada. It's also been inducted into the Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame.

Portrait Photo of Men Without Hats singer Ivan Doroschuk on stagePetter Duvander, Flickr

Advertisement

Tommy Tutone

867-5309. It's the most well-known phone number in the history of pop music and one that, should you happen to have said it as your personal phone number, will still get prank calls even to this day. "867-5309/Jenny" hit number four on the Hot 100, was named the 36th-greatest song of the 1980s by VH1. Tommy Tutone has adorned more one-hit wonder lists than we can count—but that's because we all forgot about "Angel Say No".

Tommy Heath and Jim Keller of the rock band 'Tommy Tutone'Michael Ochs Archives, Getty Images

Tommy Tutone

The year before "867-5309/Jenny", the band released the single "Angel Say No," and while it didn't do Jenny business, it did give them their first top 40 hit (peaking at 38).

View of American Pop musicians Tommy Heath (left) and Jim Keller, both of the band Tommy TutoneGary Gershoff, Getty Images

Falco

What is the only German-language song to hit number one on the Billboard Hot 100? It was Austrian singer Falco's 1986 track "Rock Me Amadeus". Which, by the way, also topped the charts in about nine other countries around the world. And for a bunch of us '80s kids, it was the reason we knew some facts about Mozart, including that he was born in Salzburg on January 27 and that he composed  The Magic Flute in 1791. But we digress.

Portrait Photo of Johann Michael Ochs Archives, Getty Images

Advertisement

Falco

Yes, the "Rock Me Amadeus" guy had another hit. He actually had a bunch of them in Europe throughout his career. But his next single, "Vienna Calling" was a legit hit in America as well—the German-rap about Falco's hometown peaked at 18 on the Hot 100.

Portrait Photo of Johann Bernd Mueller, Getty Images

Kris Kross

Kris Kross jumped into our ears back in 1992 with their double platinum smash hit "Jump", which dominated the pop charts and rocked the number one spot on the Hot 100 for eight weeks. But the Daddy Mac and the Mac Daddy weren't done with chart success just yet.

Photo of American hip hop group Kris KrossMichel Linssen, Getty Images

Kris Kross

Of course, they never had a hit like "Jump" again (few artists ever do). But the rap duo, with their clothes on backwards, actually jumped into the top 20 three more times in their careers. But if we're talking about a second hit, it's probably going to be "Warm It Up". The song hit 13 on the Hot 100, was certified gold, and landed in more charts around the world than any of their singles besides "Jump".

Rap group Kris Kross appears in a portrait taken on February 24, 1992Al Pereira, Getty Images

Advertisement

Snow

The Canadian-born rapper with the Jamaican Patois style licky boom boom down'd his way onto the charts with his 1992 single, "Informer"—off of his debut album, 12 Inches of SnowThe song spent seven weeks at number one on the Billboard Hot 100.

Portrait Photo of the Canadian Rapper and musician SnowAl Pereira, Getty Images

Snow

While most of us have forgotten that Snow put out five more albums, the fact that he had another hit song has also escaped most of our '90s music memories. But he did. The rapper followed up "Informer" with "Girl I've Been Hurt", which reached the top 10 in both Finland and Portugal, as well as cracking the top 20 in the US—peaking at 19 on the Hot 100.

Portrait Photo of Musician Snow and his wife Tara O'BrienTable222, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Spin Doctors

In 1991, the Spin Doctors made their mark with their debut album, Pocket Full of Kryptonite. Upon its initial release, the album did okay, but it was once radio stations got their hands on a couple of the songs that sales really took off. One of those songs was, of course, "Two Princes"which rose up the charts and peaked at number seven on the Hot 100. What was the other one?

Spin Doctors in a Jonathunder, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Spin Doctors

Well, interestingly enough, what many might've forgotten was that "Two Princes" was actually the second single released off of the album, the first being the almost equally-catchy "Little Miss Can't Be Wrong". The latter did well, peaking at 17 on the Hot 100 and number five on the Billboard Album Rock Tracks chart.

Spin Doctors perform on Pol’and’Rock Festival 2023Ralf Lotys, CC BY 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Sixpence None The Richer

It took Sixpence None the Richer three albums to really "make it"—but when they did it, was with the first single off of that self-titled album, and it was big. "Kiss Me" was an international hit and smooched its way up to number two on the Billboard Hot 100, selling 3 million copies and being certified three times platinum. For their follow-up single, the band went with a cover song.

Sixpence None the Richer perform at Java Rockin'Land 2013prassprasetio, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Sixpence None The Richer

"There She Goes" was originally released in 1988 by The La's and did well—eventually working its way up to 42 on the Hot 100, and NME called it the 22nd Greatest Song of All Time. Well, about a decade later, Sixpence None the Richer put their own take on the song and—in case you forgot—their version of "There She Goes" was certified gold and reached 32 on the charts.

Sixpence None the Richer perfotm at Java Rockin'Land 2013prassprasetio, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Sisqo

For anyone who was listening to the radio or watching MTV in 2000, there was no escaping "Thong Song". The greatest piece of music dedicated to a women's bathing suite since "Itsy Bitsy Teenie Weenie Yellow Polkadot Bikini" was everywhere that year and as it rose up to number three on the charts, it made the former Dru Hill lead singer a solo star. But do you remember what happened next?

Portrait Photo of Mark Althavan Andrews Sisqó performingJax 0677, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Sisqo

"Incomplete" is what happened next! To refresh all of our memories, "Incomplete" was the follow-up single to "Thong Song"—and while the latter is undoubtedly the song that most of us remember, and that made the biggest pop cultural impact, "Incomplete" was actually Sisqo's only number one hit.

Portrait Photo of Mark Althavan Andrews Sisqó performingJax 0677, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons


READ MORE

January 27, 2025 Jack Hawkins

The Most Famous TV Shows Set In Each State

America produces some excellent television, from gripping dramas to sweet romances. The American television landscape has it all. While most American TV shows are filmed in large studios in states like California, sometimes they're set in the deserts of Arizona or the wilderness of Alaska. Let's explore the most famous TV shows from every state.
Mel Brooks
January 7, 2025 Miles Brucker

Think You Remember 1974's Young Frankenstein? Try To Answer These Trivia Questions.

This movie has undoubtedly made its place as a timeless classic in American cinema. And, just like any other horror-comedy, this one has intriguing inside stories. Do you know what went into the making of this “monster-piece”?
January 28, 2025 Jillian Kent

The Weirdest Episodes Of Beloved TV Shows

Family Guy is no stranger to bizarre storylines—but there’s one weird episode that took things ways too far, leaving even die-hard fans feeling queasy.
January 23, 2025 Jane O'Shea

20 Brilliant Korean Films You Can Watch On Netflix

Can’t decide what to watch while you munch on your favorite snack? Korean cinema is here to help you out with its signature mix of suspense and heart. Here are 20 such recommendations.
Screenshot from "The River Wild" (1994)
January 20, 2025 Sarah Ng

Movie Stunts Gone Wrong

Movie stunts can be one of the most impressive aspects of a production—but they've been known to go terribly wrong. Here are some of the stunts that did not go as planned.
January 28, 2025 Binet

Scenes That Made The Movie

The scene of a deranged Jack Nicholson yelling, “Here’s Johnny!” made The Shining into one of the most famous movies in history–but few know the bizarre origin of the iconic line.